As most of you
might know by now dictatorship has been for the past decades in
developing countries. Dictatorship seem to be an ongoing political
situation in third world countries. Although other countries in the
first world have tried for many years now to bring democracy in third
world countries, it has been a complete failure for example in
Thailand and most of the middle eastern countries. This failure
might be because dictatorship in those countries has deeper roots. To
understand the roots of dictatorship one has to look at the culture
in those countries. Most third world countries have a culture of
submission. The culture of submission is “ the voluntary submission
of your dignity and perhaps your humanity to another human
being”(''Rewrite
of the Africa Dictator Handbook'').
First let's look at
African countries for example, most African countries are
dictatorships. Most African countries before colonization were lead
by Kings and elders, Africans were submissive to their leader. In
some countries for example, there were a royal tribe like Ugandan
Baganda tribe to which other tribes gave total respect and control
over them. This history of cultural submission doesn't only revolve
around the pres-colonial time but also during colonization. When
white people came to Africa, the kings thought of them as being
interesting. When the king honored those colonizers, the citizens or
Africans became “naturally submissive to the white people”
(''Rewrite
of the Africa Dictator Handbook'').
Due this cultural
relationship between leaders and citizens most African countries took
the path of dictatorship since it had more resemblance to their
culture. “It can be seen that when someone becomes president in an
African country, how all the chief, leaders and citizens will bow
down and surrender their humanity to the new leader so easily without
any examination”(''Rewrite
of the Africa Dictator Handbook'').
With this submission no one dears to question the leader or any new
policies in those countries that is why sometimes you might find a
president who has been on power for 20 years or more. For example in
Zimbabwe, their president Robert Mugabe has been who is now 89 years
of age has been on power for 33 years.
African cultures
have played in favor of Robert Mugabe and other dictators like him.
Through out their culture/history they have been submissive which
made it hard for them to contradict the leader since all they knew
was how to be submissive. “They
feared to hold the leader accountable hinders the people's ability to
fight against any abuse of power, corruption and injustice”(''Rewrite
of the Africa Dictator Handbook'').
The power sharing and power distribution system is far from the
culture of Africa, in order to incorporate them, the people of
African must be the ones wanting to change it not foreigners.
African
countries are not the only ones with a culture that influences
dictatorship but also Middle Eastern countries. Most Middle-eastern
countries are Muslim. Muslim practice Islam as their religion. “The
word Islam means ''submission'', period”(''Brutality
and Dictatorship'').
Which brings us back to the culture of submission. In this religion,
Muslim follow the teachings of the “Qur’an
and strive to keep the Five Pillars”
(''Brutality
and Dictatorship'').
More to that, Muslim means, a person who submits to Allah. “ Islam
in many ways trains people not to govern themselves but to be
governed by dictates, Muslim countries almost always are run by
dictators”(''Brutality
and Dictatorship'').
Islam as it is clearly explained above can lead to dictatorship.
Some states in the middle east wanted to incorporated Islamic laws in
their politics. These laws affect mostly women in general.
“Customary
laws,Islamic laws, imported European laws, and reformed versions of
Islamic laws affect women in''varying degrees in the different middle
Eastern legal systems, and the status of women doesn't seem to have
been settled in any of them”(''Law
and Women in the Middle East | Cultural Survival''
). An example, a woman can not ask for a divorce unless her husband
agrees.
One
might say that the culture that leads to dictatorship is a culture of
submission. This submission culture is reflected through religion and
royalty/kingdoms in third world countries like Africa and middle
east. This culture played a big role in increasing the resistance of
dictators on power by bringing fear. The fear of contradicting a more
powerful person. This fear then increased the perspective of having
more dictatorships grow in those kind of countries. Foreigners trying
to change the system have to know that it is a culture and unless the
people in the culture wants to change the system, it is practically
really hard to change it.
MLA
citation of my sources
- "Law and Women in the Middle East | Cultural Survival."Law and Women in the Middle East Cultural Survival. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Oct. 2013.
- "Rewrite of the Africa Dictator Handbook." Editorial.Africa New School of Thoughts n.d.: n. pag. Print.
- "The Christian Broadcasting Network."Brutality and Dictatorship: How Islam Affects Society: Spiritual Life on CBN.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Oct. 2013.
- "Cultural Values, Not Dictators like Libya's Qaddafi, Are Chief Obstacle to Arab Progress."The Christian Science Monitor. The Christian Science Monitor, n.d. Web. 11 Oct. 2013.
No comments:
Post a Comment